If Atheism Is A Religion...

topic posted Tue, October 13, 2009 - 5:47 AM by  Dr.Diarrhea
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
...then NOT collecting stamps is a hobby
posted by:
Dr.Diarrhea
Phoenix
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

    Tue, October 13, 2009 - 9:09 AM
    I think in order for atheists to put that "atheism is your belief" rag to bed is to establish what it is the common atheist believes exists.

    It is is everything you see around you (including yourself), the people, the world the universe, I think we are in good stead.

    Why do they always say that doing nothing is no excuse, that to do nothing is nearly the same as doing something bad?

    Don't religious people say God is totally judgmental, that he judges your every imperfect thought, that if you committed a crime in thought, you did it for real? Where does that place all the warring heads of state, who have thought of killing millions? It's just a passing thought, I'm sure.

    Why would God need to monitor all our thoughts to see if they pass spec?

    I think that is actually all the judgmental people down here.

    If Atheism is a religion, then the religious can't think. But that's not all they can't think about, the definition of religion. They are largely incapacitated as far as thought is concerned.
  • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

    Tue, October 13, 2009 - 12:45 PM
    For whatever insane reason, a significant % of responding atheists just insist on making a program of NOT collecting stamps.

    Blame them, and quit trotting out specious halfwitted logic, infidel. Just because most religious people are stupid doesn't excuse your set from the basic facts:

    • it's not about "religion" - though plenty of joyless atheist twits are set on building one for whatever dumbass reason - it's whether or not you're indulging in "belief" because, kid,
    • you can't prove a thing, and
    • your chestnuts are as stupid as theirs are, and
    • if you a believe in the absence of deity, you are even stupider than the stupidest zealot who *at least* has the consensus of zillions for *a kind* of support, however merely rhetorical.

    Face it: you're a ridiculous idiot if you care about this.
    • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

      Tue, October 13, 2009 - 1:12 PM
      I believe in nothing for which there is no evidence. Including "absence" of whatever.
      • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

        Tue, October 13, 2009 - 3:00 PM
        "I believe in nothing for which there is no evidence. Including "absence" of whatever"

        Ok...do you belive in Baal? How about Zeus? How about the green spaghetti monster with 5 eyes? There is no evidence of their absence. There is an infinite number of things that whose abscence cannot be confirmed..

        Johnny can't prove he didn't steal the candy bar, ergo he stole it. I cannot prove there isn't a tea pot orbiting mars, therefore there is.


        There is a thing Bertrand Russel talked about...sliding scale probability.
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Tue, October 13, 2009 - 3:09 PM
          For myself atheism simply living my life as of there is no god. If there was evidence for a god I would need to be convinced that he or she is worthy of worship.

          Issac Asimov once said something like this; you have a god who leaves no clear evidence for his existence. This god then says that failure to believe in him will get you punishment in a lake of fire for the rest of eternity. Why would such a god be worthy of worship or even acknowledgement?
          • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

            Tue, October 13, 2009 - 3:17 PM
            "he or she" short bus.

            "This god then says that failure to believe in him will get you punishment in a lake of fire for the rest of eternity"

            No, that was shitty humans. Pretty much most of the Bible is throwaway, just with the crackerjack secret prize of the Qabalah in it.

            You believed what those snots like Jason told you? *Bathe* in the Lake of Fire. It's like 85* warm liquid butter. Watch others who believe burn up in it. It's a fun pasttime.
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Tue, October 13, 2009 - 3:14 PM
          If Baal had some rockin' house parties, I'd believe in him. If Zeus would give me some ambrosia, I'd valet his car. The sphere of influence of the mutated FSM has not been set yet. I think this phrase "absence of evidence, evidence of absence" is merely a way to avoid thinking, like any other cliche. The candy bar is in my pants.

          Doesn't the uncertainty principle say that the viewer, in desiring either position or velocity, influences probability?
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Wed, October 14, 2009 - 1:55 PM
          Nope. There is no evidence to support the existence of Baal, Zeus, green spaghetti monsters, or whatever superstitious, irrelevant, beliefs anybody has created from whole cloth.

          I think you have misunderstood me. There is no God. I'd be happy to believe in it. Any evidence whatsoever? Miracles? Pffft. Parlor tricks.

          Bertrand Russel rocks.
      • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

        Tue, October 13, 2009 - 10:38 PM
        <I believe in nothing for which there is no evidence.>

        How then can evidence be aquired? or anything new learned? You have to be willing to believe that something could exist, before you can find that it does. You can't keep head buried under ground forever!
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Tue, October 13, 2009 - 11:18 PM
          John: "You have to be willing to believe that something could exist, before you can find that it does."

          BEING WILLING to believe that something COULD exist is far different from BELIEVING that something DOES exist, or conversely, believing that something does NOT exist.
          • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

            Wed, October 14, 2009 - 7:21 AM
            Pinky wins again. ^5
            • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

              Wed, October 14, 2009 - 1:58 PM
              • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                Wed, October 14, 2009 - 2:05 PM
                I think one of the Ten Commandments says something about "no other gods before me" so isn't that an admission that there are other gods? And since there is a virtual marketplace of gods to choose from it seems they should have to show why they are worthy of worship in the first place.

                BTW, Erik it is the Flying Spaghetti Monster. There is much discussion as to the actual color of the FSM, although most experts think it is a tomato red. May you be touched by his Noodly Appendage.
                • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                  Wed, October 14, 2009 - 3:27 PM
                  Hummingbird
                  <<<I think one of the Ten Commandments says something about "no other gods before me" so isn't that an admission that there are other gods? And since there is a virtual marketplace of gods to choose from it seems they should have to show why they are worthy of worship in the first place. >>>

                  This is a small part of my contention. I can find no reason to believe ANY of what is written regarding any diety(s) as there's no credible foundation for the claims, only supposition and ideology. And those purporting these dieties had reasons to be biased and prejudiced so as to provide their own spin on matters religious. Aside from the writers, the content published has too many flaws and contradictions to have any credibility. Based on this and the unliklihood that any diety would be so secretive and stealthy revealing itself to some and not others, I can comfortably assert that TO DATE this entity doesnt exist based on what has been presented and the faulty logic of those purporting the reasons they believe.

                  Now, I am not atheist for complicated reasons that take far too long to explain. But I have a serious problem with people taking this imagined bullshit and using imagined rules to impose them on me. Many people believe what they believe because of classical conditioning through indoctrination from parents, friends, family members and society. Here in the U.S. we have a large part of the population that are christian occultists, so most children grow up hearing and being conditioned to god and Jesus. In some other countries they grow up with muslim beliefs. My point being what people are believing in is HEARSAY and not factual evidence or anything that is inate.

                  The desire to perpetuate our species is instinctive and I think that may be one reason the hearsay is so readily accepted by many people. Some sort of promise of afterlife has been showed to be desired by civilizations down through history. But if it were fact, the ideologies would not have evolved into other unprovable ideologies. They would have evolved into fact supported by evidence.

                  There was a time when I did not care who believed what. But as we see the theist ideologies seeping more and more into legislation, I have a problem with that and it is incumbant upon those posing this crap to PROVE IT. Otherwise they need to shut the fuck up and leave me and mine alone while they take their unprovable little fantasies back to their little tea parties at the church house with like minded believers. The mere fact that we have "IN GOD WE TRUST" on our money is testimony to just how widespread the ignorance is. Trusting something that has been learned through hearsay is fucking crazy!
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                    Wed, October 14, 2009 - 3:49 PM
                    <<<The desire to perpetuate our species is instinctive and I think that may be one reason the hearsay is so readily accepted by many people. Some sort of promise of afterlife has been showed to be desired by civilizations down through history. But if it were fact, the ideologies would not have evolved into other unprovable ideologies. They would have evolved into fact supported by evidence.>>>

                    On this I'd like to add that THE ONLY ONES who have proven any truth in their beliefs were the Egyptians. They are in fact roaming the earth again as their tombs and crypts have been uncovered and their vast treasures and bodies travel abroad in exhibits. That part of their theories came to pass. They just are not the living viable people they assumed they would be in this quasi afterlife...
    • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

      Tue, October 13, 2009 - 2:56 PM
      it's not about "religion" - though plenty of joyless atheist twits are set on building one for whatever dumbass reason - it's whether or not you're indulging in "belief" because, kid,

      Who exactly are you talking about? Sounds like a straw man .

      • you can't prove a thing, and
      Exactly. Nobody can. A thing's being un-disprovable doesn't mean it is therefore true. I can't prove their ISN'T a ball point pen orbiting the M36 Galaxy either..but on a sliding scale of emprical plausibility, I can say with confidence there probably isn't. Same with luck, providence, and deity.

      • your chestnuts are as stupid as theirs are, and
      Actually, ours are not unjustifiably fabricated. Ours are smarter.

      • if you a believe in the absence of deity, you are even stupider than the stupidest zealot who *at least* has the consensus of zillions for *a kind* of support, however merely rhetorical.
      Ahh..the Appeal to Popularity..if billions..or as you say "zillions" of people belive a thing, it must be true. This is of course, not true at all. Zillions can be wrong...for example, everyone thought the earth was flat..that didn't make the earth flat. Billions thought disease was demonic possesion. That didn't stop the viruses from doing their thing.
      • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

        Tue, October 13, 2009 - 5:30 PM
        >>• your chestnuts are as stupid as theirs are, and
        Actually, ours are not unjustifiably fabricated. Ours are smarter. <<

        Sorry, hellspawn, regurgitated Christian chestnuts are not only just as stupid but now nastier and stinkier.

        It's cool and fun that you feel your chestnuts are *justifiably* fabricated, though. Touché. I will grant that concession.
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Wed, October 14, 2009 - 7:34 AM
          Is it impertinent to mention that your other points - hilariously - are entirely irrelevant to your OP's basic assertion?

          Sorry DrD. You're a great guy and I love you very tenderly, almost like a sweet hedgehog or chinchilla warmly purring in my lap, but you're a typically hasty and lazily ignorant dipshit when deity is discussed. Most people are. It stems from deliberate ignorance:

          • worshipers and positive-disbelievers (that's the name tag on the straw man's jacket, btw) alike are resistant to accepting new (to them) facts, and disdainful of the procedures by which those facts are obtained.

          • worshipers and positive-disbelievers have a preconception of reality based only on the trappings and assumptions their individual camps program with. Both artificial conventions (that is, the belief systems springing from devout theism and atheism alike) contain unsupportable assertions that are, essentially, only poetic - that is, they are artfully ordered figments of fancy. That atheists actually believe their figments are somehow "truer" than those of their theist counterparts is funny as shit.

          • Positive-atheists use the exact same goofy fallacies to support their hallucinations as the ID / god-proofers do. Semantical games and ontological doodling from atheists *ought* to be strenuously rejected by most atheists in my opinion (such behavior would likely quickly deflate the popular animus people feel toward atheists) but, like good little hooting gibbons, each time one whoops out a "there is no evidence for deity (because the bible (or any other specific scripture) is silly)" the rest seem only too excited to jump up and down whooping. I'm sure some of you still don't see how stupid "there is no evidence for deity" is. This is because you are a mob of hooting little primates, full of silliness, pooping into your hands and scampering around comically, just like your conspecific tribe of gibbering theists. The 'level of discourse' alone, on this topic, should be enough to shame *at least* the supposedly 'more intelligent' players to review their stances.
          • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

            Wed, October 14, 2009 - 9:19 AM
            I believe it was Dawkins that said we are all atheist with regards to all of the gods that have been imagined throughout human history, but some just go one god further. I have often wondered, if you can believe in one, how does one justify not believing in them all?
            • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

              Wed, October 14, 2009 - 9:38 AM
              It's a fallacy to assume that there is a binary proposition involved with deity / belief in gods / &c&al; the question reveals essential lack of understanding of deity, and poses no difficulties to anyone who simply rejects its confines.

              It is the very heart of simplicity that people believe whatever they believe. Justification is irrelevant, which is fortunate, because it's also impossible to achieve when deity (+ or -) is the question.

              Just as in the assertions of some adherents to many institutionalized forms of theism, the assertions of some atheists are based in a very *basic* mistake - something like "what I believe is necessarily true". Another basic mistake that most a/theists make is even more pernicious, I think: "God is X". It's one thing that so many believers are addicted to a picture of deity that is so compelling to them that they will cry and kill people if its scrutinized unfavorably - another entirely that *atheists*, of all freakin people, maintain a deathgrip on their interminable and doomed war with the religious concepts of specific institutions as if those concepts are definitive. WTF? You say you're an atheist - but you claim to know what God looks like? A slew of the people claiming to be atheists in my life are actually just good old fashioned Antichristians. I wish they'd cop to it and really *get in* that game, finally.

              Dr D brought up nondisprovability - it's an important concept and I think most motivated / professing atheists would do very well to consider why, in science, falsifiability is fundamental to any credible theory.
              • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                Wed, October 14, 2009 - 10:00 AM
                "Dr D brought up nondisprovability - it's an important concept and I think most motivated / professing atheists would do very well to consider why, in science, falsifiability is fundamental to any credible theory."

                I think those of us who do not believe in god can also view the existence of a god (or multiple gods) as a theory. For instance proof of the god of the bible could be if the bible predicted some discovery made by science centurys later. Or if astronauts seeing the dark side of the moon for the first time had discovered a verse from the bible carved in large letters on the surface. I think it is fair to ask for unambiguous evidence in order to prove the existence of a particualr god.
                • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                  Wed, October 14, 2009 - 10:45 AM
                  >>I think those of us who do not believe in god can also view the existence of a god (or multiple gods) as a theory.<<

                  "I agree; I think that's the best way to go about... well, doing something utterly pointless and wasteful with one's time," he said while typing a response to the HD forum regarding Dr D's quip about selective morons and how they strangle each others' brains.

                  When you have disproved the existence of the YHVH specifically mentioned in each book of the Bible, then you can get on to disproving all the cultural variations of YHVH, Jehovah, Allah, El, &c&al. Then it's onto Hindu. After that, your great-grandchildren can tackle Raven - perhaps O∂hinn, or something wild like Ajatar or maybe Azathoth (good luck: that motherfucker actually exists). OR you could cultivate an understanding of what these various myths refer to, OR you could learn enough about a single religion to understand the error you made in the first place by preferring to argue with sheep rather than undertake a sane study of your own, OR you could ignore the whole thing like that big sticky ball of goo that it is.

                  Most religions don't work the way atheists (cum Christians) think they do. That single fact alone pretty invalidates most of the argument I've seen proceed from atheist dialectic. When you proceed to philosophy from ignorance, you are being a dumbass. The belief that Streghans, for an example, "believe" in their gods the way you believe the sidewalk is under your feet when walking to the store not only misses the point of that religion 100%, it simply reveals that most Streghan talk is a zillion times smarter and more interesting than most atheist talk. Heathens, too. Some heathens make the whole of atheistdom look like whiny teens. I haven't met the atheist yet that was more crushingly logical than some of the hidebound heathens I've chatted with. These people will hard-logic-stiffarm you right into a coma.

                  I am, personally, immensely impressed by the deity of the universe. I'm habitually annoyed with the goofballs that worship it stupidly and attribute their own human failings and finiteness to it, and I've become sensitized to the paragoofballs that strain to insist "but Zeus doesn't exist!" as if that's some sort of interesting point or cogent argument. The 'Zeus' argument (appeal to ridicule) and the "if you don't believe in Gazumtäch then how can you pretend to believe in Shananay?" (false dichotomy) arguments are frivolous, ignorant, and baseless, but that is not what damns the sayer, in my eyes; what does is the acrimony that these utterly worthless tactics invite upon atheists. Yes: I am saying that I am annoyed to frustration by the way you folks idiotically heap shit on yourselves.

                  Next up:
                  ABORTION: Right, or Wrong?
    • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

      Tue, October 13, 2009 - 2:58 PM
      "• you can't prove a thing, and"

      This is true. Nothing can be proven directly. But indirectly...

      Do atheists worship the human form? Did they set up little idols of pagan gods?

      Suppose we were all alive back, say, 3850 B.C.E. What are we thinking? It that Horus battling Set in the sky, or a comet? Are big people walking around in the holy precinct of the mesopotamian ziggurat telling priest-kings what to teach the people?

      It's nice that in this era we can apply the radicalness of a scalpel of logic to all these ancient ideas.

      Oops, a demon just made me sneeze. And that stupid cur who stole his neighbors wife got cursed by him, he must believe in voodoo.

      Isn't most of that just a more complex version of voodoo? What's salvageable from it?
      • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

        Tue, October 13, 2009 - 5:25 PM
        Irrelevant.

        Appealing to the absurdity of certain religious concepts is 100% irrelevant to the absurdity of deliberately irreligious concepts. Might as well say the shittiness of "Friends" proves the hilarious awesomeness of "Seinfeld". But then again - that topic would at least have something to do with something.
        • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

          Tue, October 13, 2009 - 6:20 PM
          • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

            Wed, October 14, 2009 - 9:15 AM
            Ha! My wife and I were just discussing that skit at dinner last night *because Friends was on the TV at the restaurant* and I mentioned my analogy about a/theism : friends v seinfeld. Saith she, "that one bit with the chess game between the dick and the brain was funny".

            She read the thread this morning, and laughed goofily at Dr D's handle. She's totally silly like that.
            • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

              Wed, October 14, 2009 - 2:02 PM
              So, do you have any evidence to support your contention for the existence of a God?

              Ever read Professor Victor Stenger? Check out "God: The Failed Hypothesis" and get back to us.
              • Re: If Atheism Is A Religion...

                Thu, October 15, 2009 - 11:14 AM
                Actually, perfesser, you'll find I make no such claim. Slow down, and try hard not to be so hasty in revealing the slothful habits of your clunky mind. Take your time, read things over, ask yourself if you have enough facts to make a solid inference - when you don't, ask questions that collect data instead of experimenting too early with assumptions.

                Stenger makes the same stupid blunders as all the atheist spokepersons do. Like them, he should come out against religions he doesn't care for and quit pretending to have any more compelling logic than "Flash Gordon is stronger than Buck Rogers". His book contains incisive and valid criticism, but it will be ignored, because he is intellectually dishonest. That religious proponents are at least equally so is no defense for Mr Stenger.

Recent topics in "Heated Debate"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
When I Say "I Am A Christian" offlinePinky 49 Yesterday, 11:15 PM
Jason claims Woodie Guthrie was not political Josh 8 Yesterday, 10:59 PM
christmas alone Reggie 12 Yesterday, 10:55 PM
jason leary queer Hector 26 Yesterday, 12:07 PM