It Is Legal to Blaspheme

topic posted Sun, November 1, 2009 - 6:44 AM by  Hummingbird
Share/Save/Bookmark
Advertisement
atheism.about.com/library/d...Wilson.htm

"In a unanimous ruling, the Supreme Court agreed with the plaintiff's arguments and struck down the New York State law allowing for "sacrilegious" films to be banned from public showings. According to the Court, films are an important medium for communicating ideas in society, something not lessened by the fact that they are also designed to entertain. Expression by means of film thus deserves the same protections of liberty under the First Amendment as those for newspapers, books, magazines, etc.

The idea that some form of expression can be banned because it is deemed "sacrilegious" was rejected for two reasons. First, the standard was too vague......."

This unanimous US Supreme Court Decision still resonates into the 21st century. It means that anything from Maplethorp's "Piss Jesus" picture to the Danish cartoon of Mohammed are considered protected speech under the First Amendment. In other words in America the first Ten Amendments to the Constitution (the Bill of Rights) trumps the 10 Commandments. Religion holds no special place that allows it to be free from satire or ridicule. Just as we can make jokes about Congress or any politican so can we make jokes at the expense of religion or religious symbols or deities.
Advertisement
Advertisement
  • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

    Sun, November 1, 2009 - 8:32 AM
    • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

      Sun, November 1, 2009 - 9:57 AM
      Actually, it was "Piss Christ" by Andres Serrano, that I believe you were referring to.

      www.artnet.com/artwork/42...christ.html

      Mapplethorpe did a ton of cool shit though. He was the one they tried to prosecute the director of the museum in Cincinnati for exhibiting.

      I'm actually more careful here, in Europe, as my work is totally blasphemous, and there are actually laws against it.

      erikchristiansen.deviantart.com/
      • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

        Sun, November 1, 2009 - 10:08 AM
        thanks for the correction, Erik.
        • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

          Sun, November 1, 2009 - 1:08 PM
          I had someone tell me that my injury is a direct result of my blasphemy.Ha!Ha! To wit I replied "If this is true, then god is going to make me very wealthy for cussing his bitch ass." Religion is blasphemy towards intelligence and reality. So fuck the zealots and their god!
          • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

            Sun, November 1, 2009 - 1:16 PM
            Along those same lines I once pissed of a charlatan who claimed to be a shaman. (I was with some fellow skeptics who asked some questions that he could not answer) the plastic shaman and his followers said they were going to do a ritual as a way to curse and punish me. The very next day I was informed of an unexpected financial windfall. I wrote back and asked them for another ritual. The "shaman" kept uttering trite new age nonsense like "there is no such thing as a coincidence" I doubted that until I realized that the word sham is right before the word shaman in the dictionary.
            • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

              Sun, November 1, 2009 - 9:56 PM
              keep trying
              morons...
              you are not even
              nor
              close
              • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

                Mon, November 2, 2009 - 9:51 AM
                Nice literary flourish there.

                And you call others "morons" eh?

                Still no source for your last lie?
                • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

                  Mon, November 2, 2009 - 1:59 PM
                  don't wish i even had the time

                  but since you mention it
                  GAZA: where tens of thousands of women, children and babies were murdered by the big bad mossad
                  and the mighty isreali military
                  or was it
                  JFK murder and coverup
                  RFK murder and coverup?
                  jfk jr murder and coverup; real slick how the pentagon stepped in and took over and wow...some tv station located the beam
                  from the plane...because the pentagon with the best equipment could not find it...
                  9-11 better than perfect contolled demolition?
                  bin laden then deserves a nobel prize...for controlled demo
                  federal reserve bank?
                  maybe
                  it was FEMA
  • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

    Tue, November 3, 2009 - 12:42 PM
    It's because Yahweh & Co. are a pack of unrepentant pedophiles, murderers, rapists and all-around terrible monstrous assholes.

    I say anyone who actually voluntarily worships these gods and their spokespersons are either dangerously stupid or criminally evil (or the alternative, of course).
    • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

      Tue, November 3, 2009 - 12:52 PM
      Isn't it funny how the unreasonable irrational people always manages to shove their way to the podium, the pulpit or the boardroom table?

      One thing I also find amusing, their morality and way of life is so superior to everybody else's, it's so great and so wonderful, but apparently it is so fragile and prone to being corrupted that it has to be kept away from ANY other influence or else it'll be destroyed.

      Proof that the God-ists are utterly immune to reason, as the natural conclusion would be that the superior morality is the one that invades and breaks down the inferior ones. Similarly, inferior moral codes can only survive at the point of a gun, which is usually the way the God-ists insist their own beliefs be enforced. Coincidence?
    • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

      Tue, November 3, 2009 - 12:53 PM
      Loki you filthy Godless blasphemer , repent or make yourself painlessly catatonic with a long comfortable life in a catonic state .

      Yahweh is the freind of strangers , of widows and orphans , and the poor .
      • Re: It Is Legal to Blaspheme

        Tue, November 3, 2009 - 3:07 PM
        Your pathetic volcano totem is the widowmaking rapist of children, you perverted defiling monster. Yahweh is the estranger of friends, an archetypal brute that punishes and exploits the poor - this foul and imbecilic little haint you worship is nothing more than an idiot ape obsessed with penises and roaring like a child whenever simple reasoning is invoked.

        Your voluntary fellatio of this monster will not save you from Hell, however. You've repeatedly and proudly broken your Yahweh's commandments, sinned against His creations, bore false witness, and claimed His judgment for your own, and so will perish in the Lake of Fire. Idiot Ape's boy, the magic hippie, tried to give you a way out but you *ignored* the wisdom of Jesus. Burn, sinner-ape, burn. I will gnaw and slurp on your fatted soul.

Recent topics in "Heated Debate"